| Names | When & how Admitted | When & how Dismissed | Remarks |
| Alfred Pelton
Eliza Ann Pelton } |
These four were organized into a church | By letter to Presb. Chh. Naples
April 16, 1845 |
|
| Timothy Bruen
Mary Bruen } |
Oct. 30, '42, by letter to Geneva | ||
| Charles Clement Sheppard
Jane Bradley - Sheppard } |
Feb. 28, '41: On professn | to Pres Chh Penn Yan Oct 20 '56 | |
| " " | " " | ||
| William Comstock
Mary Cooley - Comstock } |
" " | ||
| " " | |||
| Joseph Elmendorf
Catherine Elmendorf } |
" " | ||
| " " | |||
| Elizabeth Lewis, Widow | " " | ||
| Catherine Ellis do | " " | to Corning Pre. Chh Apl 1 '53 | |
| Caroline Holmes | " " | ||
| Belinda Crouch | " " | Withdrawn, Excluded Jan 3, 1844 | |
| Leander Reddy | " " | ||
| Rachel Reddy | " " | ||
| Roscius Morse | " " | ||
| Mary Ann Morse | " " | ||
| Henry Bradley | " " | ||
| Rhoda Ann Bradley | " " | ||
| Miles Benham | " " | ||
| Henry Child Morse | " " | Letter to Hadley, Mass. 12 Apl 1843 | |
| George Cooley | Feb. 28, '41 - On professn | ||
| Harriet Stewart, Widow | " " | ||
| Sarah F Sheppard, Sheldon | " " | Died Oct 5, '49 | |
| Cornelia D Hickock, Brigden | " " | ||
| Susan W Baker | " " | 11 June, 1843: to Akron, O. | |
| William H Scram | " " | Dec'r 28, 1843, - to Syracuse | |
| James Cooley | " " | ||
| George Benham | " " | to Presb Chh Penn Yan Feby 4 '53 | |
| Joseph Millspaugh
Mary Millspaugh } |
Mar 3rd | ||
| " " | |||
| Daniel Millspaugh | " " | ||
| Sarah Jane Scram (Mrs W H) | " " | Dec'r 28, 1843, to Syracuse | |
| Charles White
Elizabeth White } |
" " | ||
| " " | |||
| Abraham Miller | " " | to Auburn | |
| Daniel Conger | " " | to Auburn 1st Presb Chh: Apl 1845 | |
| Briggs Belknap
Miami Belknap } |
" " | Dismissed by peaceful & happy death
August 1, 1842 -- -- |
|
| " " | |||
| Mary Eliza Belknap | " " | Died in fullness of Christian Love June, 1843 | |
| Nancy Millspaugh, - Davis | " " | ||
| Mary Ann Hamlin (Mrs Myron) | |||
| Henrietta Sophia Peck, Marsh | " " | Widow | |
| Edward B Walsworth | " " | Aug. '44 - By letter to Pres chh: Walworth
Wayne Co |
|
| Sarah Cornwell (Mrs Wm) | " " | ||
| William Taylor
Margaret Taylor } |
" " | ||
| " " | |||
| Charles Wesley Taylor | Mar 3, 1841 On profess. | ||
| James Franklin Taylor | " " | 22 Sep '48 to Amherst Mass. | |
| Helen Mar Kelsey | " " | ||
| Catharine Dedrick, Randall | " " | ||
| Susan Atkinson Jones,Holbrook | " " | By letter, Feb 1845, to Cong Chh Whitesboro | |
| Ann Nicholas Jones Jennings | " " | Letter to Waverly Feby 4, 1851 | |
| Julia Ann Pelton, - Cole | " " | ||
| Henry Perrine
Fanny Perrine } |
" " | excommunicated Aug 19/51 | |
| " " | Died | ||
| William S Millspaugh
Hannah Millspaugh } |
" " | Letter to Cong Ch. Clinton Mich Nov 25/54 | |
| " " | do do | ||
| Isaac Joshua Belknap | " " | ||
| James M Maclean | " " | Geneva - First | |
| Samuel Kersey Jones | " " | letter to Sparta Manor Wiss. [- illegible -] | |
| Adelia Benham | Mar. 7 | March '46 By letter to Geneva | |
| Amanda K Benham, - Bennett | " " | July, '42: By letter to New York City | |
| Sarah Ann Whitaker | " " | Died | |
| Celestia Benham, Babcock | " " | Letter | |
| Rebecca Crafts (Mrs. | " " | ||
| Phebe Dixon Dale | " " | to Cong Chh Elmira Apl 1/53 | |
| Helen M Stewart, Benson | " " | By letter Feb 1845. to An. Presby Chh. In Montreal, Canada | |
| Mary Curtis (Mrs. | " " | ||
| Frances Millspaugh | Branch Port | ||
| James F Cady | Mar 20 | June 13 '41: Letter to Michigan | |
| Lyman Munger
Martha S Munger } |
" " | ||
| " " | |||
| Cornelia Zillah Elmendorf,Winants | " " | ||
| Eliza M Miner (Mrs. Ovid) | Mar 20: On profess. | Aug 9 1846 to Syracuse | |
| James Alden Belknap | " " | Aug 1843 - By letter to Branchport | |
| Sarah Ann Belknap | " " | ||
| Mary Ann Winants, Miller | " " | Dismissed to Auburn | |
| Mary Ann Jones (Mrs S K) | " " | Letter to Sparta, Wis. Congr. Church | |
| John Hall Bruen | Mar 23 | ||
| Priscilla Ackerman (Mrs | " " | to Corning Pres. Chh Apl 1/53 | |
| Pamela Winants (Mrs Luther) | " " | ||
| Elizabeth Rice, Widow | " " | Died Sept 9, 1854 | |
| David Millspaugh
Jane Millspaugh } |
Mar 28 | Died | |
| " " | Died | ||
| Epha Millspaugh | " " | ||
| Russel R Fargo
Mary Fargo } |
" " | Letter to Pulteney Nov 19/51 | |
| " " | Died | ||
| Mary Smith Lee | May 22 | Aug 15, '41: - By Letter to Penfield, Monroe | |
| Joseph Breck
Elizabeth Breck } |
May 23: By letter |
By Letter, Aug 16, 1843 |
|
| " " | |||
| Thomas Holbrook
Nancy Holbrook } |
" " | ||
| " " | |||
| Howard R Miller | " On profess. | Apr 5th/57 Letter to Plymouth Church Br. | |
| James Benham
Julia Benham } |
" " |
March 1843, - By Letter to Hammondsport, St. |
|
| " " | |||
| Maria Augusta Harvey | " " | Died | |
| E. Elizabeth A. Gieger, Widow, Sackett | " " | By Letter to Cong Chh Rushville | |
| Oliver Coleman
Nancy Coleman } |
July 4 | ||
| " " | |||
| Jane Benham (Mrs George) | July 4: 1841 On profess. | to Pres. Chh Penn Yan Feby 4/53 | |
| Samuel S Elwood
Pertilla Elwood } |
" " | ||
| " " | |||
| Sarah Henry, Widow | " " | July '42: By letter | |
| Mary Taylor | " By Letter | ||
| Peter Cooley | July 11: On profession | Died Feb 1858 | |
| Catharine H Bennett | " " | Letter Feby 18/52 | |
| Penelope Elder (Mrs. | " " | 12 Apl 47 to Newfield NY | |
| Joseph Jones
Susan Jones } |
Sept 3: " | died | |
| " " | Letter to Buffalo Mar 21/52 | ||
| John Norcott
Sarah Norcott } |
" " | ||
| " " | |||
| John Elliott Benton | Oct 14: " | Nov 1843, - By Letter to NY City | |
| Mary Lockwood | Nov 5: " | May '42: By letter to Groton, Tompkins Co | |
| Maria Root, Prosser | Dec 31: By Letter | ||
| Phebe Wing (Mrs. | " " | Aug '42: By Letter to Prattsburgh | |
| Augusta S Winants (Mrs Alvin | " On profess. | ||
| Harriet Newell Wise, Fargo | " " | ||
| William Thomas | Feb 1842: " | ||
| Pennina Miller (Mrs. | Feb 25: By Letter | June '42: By letter to Michigan | |
| Phebe Huntington, (Mrs. | " On profess. | ||
| Catherine Hayes | " " | ||
| Nelson Ellsworth | Mar 30. | Feby '46 By letter to Columbus, Ohio | |
| Morris M Ford | " By Letter | ||
| Marcia Ann Dunlap, Breck | " " | By letter to Chh Vienna | |
| Scepter Smith | " On profess. | March, 1843, by letter to Cong: Chh McLean, Tompkins Co | |
| Ambrose Spencer | Mar 30: 1842 - on profess. | To 1st Pres: Chh: Aubuen 1844 | |
| George Hancock | " " | Angelica | |
| Elizabeth Rice, Miss | " " | ||
| Charity Cooley (Mrs. George) | " " | ||
| Catharine Gayton, Thomas | " " | Col. | |
| Anna Hoyt (Mrs. | " " | Deceased | |
| Caroline King | April 4: " | May '42: By letter, to Vienna, Ont Co | |
| Persis Caroline Babcock (Mrs Wood) " | |||
| Harriet Joy Reddy (Mrs Hawley) " " | Died | ||
| Elizabeth Murdock (Mrs | " " | ||
| Sarah Austin Bruen | " " | ||
| Elisha Steele
Jane Steele } |
" " | Dec 1844, - By letter, to Dr
Springs Pres. Chh, New York |
|
| " By Letter | |||
| Mary A Coleman | " On profess. | Died Sep 21st '55 | |
| Sarah Jane Winants Mrs Lee | Apr 23: " | West | |
| Elizabeth Squires | " " | Dec 28, 1843, - to Meth. Epis. Chh | |
| Henry Baldwin Cornwell | " " | Excluded, Aug 16, 1843 | |
| Sarah Saunders (Mrs | " " | Excommunicated Dec 24, 1851 | |
| Lydia Stark, Widow | Ap. 24: By letter | ||
| Edward R Briggs
Ann Elizabeth Kelsey, Briggs } |
May 1. On profession | ||
| " " | |||
| Nancy E Cookingham | June 15: By letter | To Prattsburgh by letter, Aug 1843 | |
| James H Gallaher | July 3: " | Excommunicated Aug 20, 1846 | |
| Clarissa Gallaher | " " | Letter to Elmira Feby 4 1851 | |
| Caroline M Conger (Mrs Danl) | Aug. 24: " | To 1st Pres: Chh Auburn | |
| John W Thomas | Aug 24: By letter | Colored | |
| Eliza Drew, Widow Losey | Aug 27: " | ||
| Morse Stewart | Sept 2: On profess. | Mar 1843 By letter to Detroit, Mich. | |
| Augusta Stewart, Dey | " " | Sept 1843 " " to Detroit - | |
| Susan Hibbard | Oct 19. - By letter | q 17 Jan, 1849 | |
| Jerusha B Robbins, Mrs | " " | ||
| Cyrus M Hawley
Cornelia M Hawley } |
" " | Mar '44 By letter to Hamilton NY | |
| " " | Mar '44 By letter to Hamilton NY | ||
| Catherine Murphy Lowry | Mar 12: '43 - On Prof. | Died | |
| Betsey C Andrews, (Widow) | " By letter | ||
| Cornelius S Boice
Puella Boice } |
" " | 26 Jul - Excom | |
| " " | gone west | ||
| Alonzo DeWolf | " " | Letter to Meth. Chh Bath Nov 19/51 | |
| Ellen M DeWolf | " " | do | do |
| Andrew Lucas | Apl 30: By letter | Aug '43 - by letter to the West | |
| Adelia Steele (Mrs Geo S) | " " | to Cong Chh Elmira Apl 1/53 | |
| Hannah Sweet | " On prof. | removed | |
| Emily Cornwell | " " | gone west | |
| Thomas Hamilton | " " | removed | |
| Amos Fowler | " " | removed | |
| Deborah Varney | July 2. On prof. | Mar '46 By letter to Geneva | |
| Abram F Hazen | " " | Letter to Presb. Church Henry St Brooklyn NY | |
| Morgan DeWitt Tracy | " " | Pulteney, Steuben Co | removed |
| Cornelia M Crane | Nov. By letter | to Vernon Centre Pre Chh Apl 2/53 | |
| Cynthia Benham, Mrs | March '44 " | Syracuse | removed |
| Catharine Seabrook | " " | united with the western [- ? -] | |
| Rodney Brown
Cathaline Jane Brown } |
March '44 - By letter | ||
| " On prof. | Died | ||
| Myron Hamlin | " " | Letter to Pres. Church Mar 17/52 | |
| Ann W Mallory (Mrs Barnaba | Oct '44. By letter | Sept 7 '45 by Letter to the West | |
| Mary V Babcock, Stiles | Dec. " " | 5 Apl '48 | |
| Maryette Cronk (Mrs. | " " | removed | |
| Lydia Whitney (Mrs. | " " | removed | |
| Irena F White (Mrs Daniel) | " " | 8 Nov '46 to Havana NY | |
| Henry B Stiles | March '45 " | 5 April 1848 | |
| Mary A Denison (Mrs. | " " | 16 Jany '48 | |
| Catherine Parsons (Mrs. | " " | 7th Febry /57 Cong Church Albion [- illeg. -] | |
| Sherman Morse | " " | [- illegible -] | |
| William P Lee | " " | 29 Apl '49 to Clarksville O. | |
| Elizabeth Lee | " " | " " " " | |
| Alvin Winants | " On prof. | Withdrawn Excluded May 29/46 | |
| George W Chamberlin | " " | ||
| Nancy Sprague (Mrs. | " " | ||
| John Mulford Minisee | May 4 " | Colored | |
| Sarah Hall (Mrs. Thos | " " | 8 Nov '46 to Minor's | |
| Henry Bennett | " " | 12 Octr '48 to New Haven Ct | |
| Lucy Deborah Wright Bruen | " " | ||
| Augustus Coleman | " " | ||
| Nancy Jane Wright | " " | [- illegible -] | |
| Edward Welles | " " | ||
| Nehemiah Denton
Hannah Denton } |
May 18. By letter | ||
| " " | |||
| William D Henry
Minerva Henry } |
July 5, 1845 By letter | Letter to Wesleyan church June 22/51 | |
| " " | to Cong church Jamestown May 15/53 | ||
| Ovid Miner | 1 Feby 1846 By profess. | Augt.9.46 to Syracuse | |
| Henry Crafts | 31 May '46 By profess. | removed | |
| John McKay
Emily McKay } |
31 May '46 By letter | 28 May '48 to Geneva | |
| " " | |||
| Sarah French | " " | 10 March '47 by letter | |
| Daniel White | some years ago but not entrd | 8 Nov '46 to Havana NY | |
| M A Adams [sic] | 4 Nov '46 By letter | to Lyons Pres. Ch. Apl 11/53 | |
| Levi Hoyt | " By profession | 30 Decr '49 by Letter | |
| Amelia P Gillett | A[-?-] C Gillett's wife | ||
| Abraham Miller | 11 June '47 by letter | ||
| Mary Ann Miller | " " | ||
| Marietta Crane | 15 Oct '47 by letter | ||
| Rachel Elmendorf | " " | May 31/57 by Letter | |
| Benjamin L Hoyt | 14 Jany '48 on profess. | ||
| Mrs Martin | " By letter | Died Spring 1849 | |
| Delancey Martin | 14 April '48 on profess. | Dead | |
| Leander Freary | " " | 18 Nov 1849 | |
| Alexander H Millspaugh | " " | ||
| Sophia E Elwood | [- illegible -] | ||
| Emily Balls | " " | [- illegible -] | |
| James H Leonard | " " | ||
| John Soule | " " | ||
| Francis H Rugar | " " | certificate of membership | |
| Henry Olmstead | " " | to Cong Chh Ripon Wis Oct 26 '56 | |
| Sophronia Reddy | 14 April '48 on profess. | ||
| Alexander Allen | " " | Excommunicated Oct 22/51 | |
| Joseph B Breck | " " | ||
| James Benham | 20 April '48 on prof. | To Pre. Chh Penn Yan Feby 4. 1853 | |
| Henry R Foote | " " | 17 Jany '49 Excom. | |
| Maria Barnard | " " | ||
| Mrs Elizabeth Allen | " " | Letter to Nelsons Augt 19/51 | |
| Harriet Yelverton | " " | ||
| Catharine Wright | " " | to Pres. Ch. Albany Augt 5/53 | |
| Caroline Sutherland | " " | ||
| Mary Ann Elwood Mrs[-illeg-] | " " | Died [-illeg-] 1854 | |
| Mary Reddy | " " | ||
| Augusta Taylor | " " | 30 Apl '48 | |
| Francis Barnard | " " | ||
| Mary Whittaker | " " | removed | |
| Mary Jane Rice | " " | Died | |
| Sarah Birdsall | " " | 11 July '49 Excom. | |
| Francis M Potter | 21 Apl '48 on prof. | Cf. of membership 1 Apl /52. Jany 21/53 | |
| Alfred W March | " " | Apr 1st 55 | |
| Josepha Whittaker | " " | ||
| Harriet Jones (Mrs. [- illeg. -] ) | " " | to Presb Chh Penn Yan May 10 '52 | |
| Jane Sheppard | " " | to Presb Church Penn Yan Oct 20 '56 | |
| Phoebe Morehouse | " " | ||
| David Ogden Bradley | " " | ||
| Margaret Benham | " " | to Pres. Chh Feby 4 '53 in Penn Yan | |
| Jane Hopkins | " " | to Pres. Church Croton Falls Westchester Co | |
| Eunice Allen | " " | to Pres. Church Port Byron Mar 12/?? | |
| Lucinda Wheeler | 21 Apl '48 on profession | ||
| Milton H Gallagher | " " | removed | |
| Henry R Taylor | " " | ||
| Zarlino Nash | 22 Apl '48 on profession | to Cong Church St Pauls Minissotta
March 25/54 -- changed his name |
|
| Nathan Morehouse | " " | ||
| Mary Page | " " | removed | |
| Jane Northrup | " " | Mar 4/54 to Pre Ch Hornellsville NY | |
| Susan A Huntington Charles | 25 Apl '48 on profession | ||
| Daniel White | 22 Sep '48 by letter | Letter to Havana June 15/51 | |
| Irene F White | " " | do do | |
| Henry Hubbard | " " | ||
| Joseph Beach | 1 Decr '48 by letter | by letter | |
| Margaret Clump | 8 June '49 on profession | ||
| Mrs Mary Hazen Abm F | " " | ||
| Claudine B Brace | " " | Letter to Pres. Church Apl 21/52 | |
| Sarah E Taylor | 1 Decr '49 on profession | Letter to Dutch Reformed Chh Farmersville NY | |
| Levi Mason | 1 " by letter | ||
| Cynthia J Mason | " " | ||
| Almira A Clarke | 21 June '50 by letter | to Franklin Cong Chh Nov 21/52 | |
| Helen E Clarke | " " | to Franklin Cong Chh Nov 21/52 | |
| Mary M Clarke | " " | to Franklin Cong Chh Nov 21/52 | |
| Mabry C Young | 2 Augt '50 by letter | to Amsterdam Pres Chh Nov 21/52 | |
| Lois A Young | " " | to Amsterdam Pres Chh Nov 21/52 | |
| Cynthia Bacon | " " | open letter Sep 6th 1857 | |
| Sarah Bacon Bates | 7 Feby '51 by letter | to Pres church Dubuque Iowa June 23rd /56 | |
| Enos Olmstead | 5 July '51 by letter | ||
| Mrs Stark | 51 Novr 19 on profess. | to Pres. Ch Springwater Valley May 10/51 | |
| Frances Olmstead | 52 Jany 2 Letter | Letter to Bellona Apr 25th 1853 | |
| Cynthia Olmstead | do do | " " " | |
| Emeline Olmstead | do do | ||
| Elizabeth Cornwell | 52 March 5 Letter | ||
| Isabella Adams | 52 March 5 profession | to Lyons Pres. Ch. Apl 1/53 | |
| Frances Cornwell | do do | Died Oct 31, 1855 | |
| Mrs Frances Rapalee Taylor | 52 Oct 29 Letter | ||
| Mrs laura Hughson | 53 Jany 19 Letter | Sept 24 1854 Open letter | |
| Mrs George Cook | 53 April 1 Letter | ||
| Rev. S S Hughson | 53 Augt 1 Letter | Sept 24 1854 Open letter | |
| John B Bacon | 53 Augt 1 Certificate | [- illegible -] | |
| James F Taylor | " Oct 2 Letter | ||
| Mrs Charlotte R Mills | 54 Feby 3 Letter | ||
| Ruth Carson | " Feby 3 Letter | Oct 4th 1857 letter to Cong Chh [- ? -] Herkimer Co NY | |
| Mrs Electa Vincent | " March 11 Letter | ||
| Charles B Reed | " " " | to Pres Ch Marengo Ill Augt 11/54 | |
| Mrs Hannah E Bacon | " " Certif. | To Cong ch. La Crosse Wis Aug /?? | |
| Aaron F Cowles | " " Letter | ||
| Artemas Bigelow | " " Profess. | to Cong Ch Newark NJ Sept 24/54 | |
| Elizabeth S Bigelow | " " do | do do do | |
| Edward Glass | " " do | to Pres church Corning Mar 25/54 | |
| Ovid M Reddy | /54 March 25 Profession | ||
| John S Sheppard | " " " | to Pres church Penn Yan Oct 20/56 | |
| George C Gould | " " " | ||
| Franklin B Brown | " " " | ||
| David Millspaugh | " " " | to Cong Church Clinton Mich. Dec ?/56 | |
| Mrs Cornelia B Bennett | /54 March 25 Profession | to the Pilgrims Church Brooklyn Feb ?? 57 | |
| Jone T Munger | " " " | to Cong Ch Oberlin O. Decr 30/54 | |
| Frances Curtiss | " " " | to Cong chh Centerville Mass Apl 26/54 | |
| Emogene Elmendorf | " " " | By Letter May 3rd 1857 | |
| Martha M Elwood | " " " | ||
| Mrs Olmstead | " " " | ||
| Caroline Cornwell | " " " | ||
| Julia E pomeroy | " " " | ||
| Margaret Thomas | " " " | ||
| Elizabeth Waldron | " " " | ||
| Sophia Reddy | " " " | May 30th /58 to Presb. Church Penn Yan | |
| Sophia Huntington | " " " | " " " " " | |
| Julia A Wright | " " " | ||
| Melissa Doughtery | " " " | to Presbyterian Church Penn Yan | |
| Elizabeth A Reddy | " " " | to Presb. Church Penn Yan May 30th 1858 | |
| Lucy A Sm-- | " " " | ||
| Ann Eliza Jones | " " " | to Meth Ch. West Dresden Jany 13/55 | |
| Mary Elizabeth Jones | " " " | ||
| Martha Brown | " " " | ||
| Mrs Helen A Cowles | /54 June 4 Certif. | ||
| Sarah E Coleman | /55 Nov 2nd on Profess. | ||
| Ovid Miner Taylor | /56 Mar " " | ||
| Orett Munger | " " " | ||
| Louisa Bacon | " " " | Open letter Sep 6th /57 | |